Roof Replacement in the Gregory section from $9,500. New Jersey prices, a written scope, and a contract you are allowed three days to think about. Free inspection and a written quote.
Substantial older houses under heavy canopy, which changes what a replacement has to solve. The covering may be failing on the shaded slopes years before the sunlit ones, and valleys that sit full of leaf litter have usually been wet far longer than the ceiling below them suggests. Both get surveyed before a scope is written.
An architectural asphalt roof in New Jersey runs $9,500 to $26,000, and most 2,000 square foot houses land at $12,000 to $18,000 installed. Architectural shingle is $5.50 to $8.00 per square foot against $4.50 to $6.50 for three-tab. On a house you intend to keep, the heavier product is worth the difference; on one you are selling next spring, it may not be, and a quote that does not ask which you are doing has not asked enough.



Those are New Jersey figures for an architectural asphalt roof, and most 2,000 square foot houses land at $12,000 to $18,000 installed. In West Orange the number moves most with which side of the mountain the house is on: a steep, broken up First Mountain roof is a different job from a post-war slope out towards Pleasantdale. Canopy does the work here. Debris-packed valleys, gutters that fill between clearings and shaded slopes that never dry mean the roof often needs attention years before its age would suggest -- and the valley and gutter detail is where the money is best spent.
A simple roof shape, a driveway to work from, a deck that turns out sound, and a detached one- or two-family house -- which in most of this township means ordinary maintenance and no permit to wait on.
Pitch and geometry first: dormers, valleys and turrets add time per square that area alone never shows. Then a sloping wooded site that has to be staged, board sheathing that has to be made good, and a second covering that has to come off.
How decking replacement is priced. It belongs in the scope as a rate per sheet, because nobody knows how much has softened until the covering is off, and a lump figure is a guess in one direction or the other.
Trees are the specific problem here. Mature canopy over a roof means debris in the valleys, gutters that fill faster than they drain, and slopes that stay damp long enough to grow moss. None of that is dramatic, and all of it shortens a covering that would otherwise have years left.
On a shaded street, the gutter run and the valley detail are worth more attention than the choice of shingle.
Three of them you can do standing in your own driveway, before anybody gets a ladder off a roof rack. Apply them here first.
N.J.A.C. 13:45A-17.11 requires the registration number on BOTH sides of a commercial vehicle used for home improvement work, with "HIC reg. #" in lettering an inch high. An unmarked van is not a matter of taste or opinion -- it is a vehicle that does not comply with the rule it is supposed to.
Over $500, N.J.A.C. 13:45A-16.2 requires it in writing and signed by both parties, setting out the work and the materials and giving the contractor's legal name and business address. A first name and a mobile number is not a business address.
That contract must carry a bold Notice to Consumer giving you three business days to cancel, running to midnight of the third business day after you receive your copy. Anyone telling you the price is only good today is describing something the law will not enforce for them.
Under mature oaks the recurring repair is not a hole -- it is a valley.
Under this much canopy the storm damage is as likely to be a limb as the wind itself.
Slate under heavy tree cover grows moss and holds damp on the shaded slopes, which does not harm the stone but does work on everything holding it.
A flat roof under mature trees is a debris trap, and a blocked outlet on a low-slope deck does not overflow harmlessly the way a gutter does -- it ponds until it finds a seam.
Under this canopy the inspection pays attention to the shaded slopes, the valleys and the gutter runs, because that is where a roof in this section ages first.
One township, two trades. The mountain decides.
An 1850s planned community. Real slate, real frames.
Post-war and simple. The layer count is the variable.
High and exposed. Edges first, access second.
Denser and more multi-family. Unit count decides it.
Large, simple, accessible. Age is the question.
Inter-war stock. Board decking and narrow lots.
The questions this job turns on, answered up front.
Only where it has actually softened, and as a rate per sheet in the written scope rather than a lump guess. On the older stock here the deck is frequently board sheathing rather than plywood, which holds a nail differently -- so it is established by lifting and looking before anything is specified on top of it.
Only over one existing layer, on a sound deck. Two coverings is the practical ceiling, and an overlay buries the eaves detail -- so if there was never an ice barrier down there, an overlay guarantees there still is not. In this climate that is the wrong saving.
For a standard asphalt roof on an average house, yes -- that is well above the $12,000 to $18,000 most 2,000 square foot houses cost here. But it is an entirely normal figure for natural slate, for a large house, or for a steep and complicated roofline with towers and dormers, which this township has a good deal of. The number on its own does not answer the question. What the quote itemizes does.
Architectural asphalt typically gives 20 to 30 years here and three-tab 15 to 20, with freeze and thaw at the eaves doing more to shorten both than sunlight does. Natural slate outlasts the rest by a wide margin -- often a century or more -- which is why so many slate roofs in this area need their nails, valleys and flashings attended to rather than the stone replaced.
A 1,200 square foot roof in architectural shingle works out at roughly $6,600 to $9,600 on New Jersey rates, before anything the roof itself adds. Note that 1,200 square feet of FLOOR is not 1,200 square feet of roof: pitch, overhangs and dormers mean the roof area on a house that size is commonly a third larger again, which is a frequent source of quotes that look inexplicably far apart.
The registration number on the paperwork, not just the website. A written scope over $500, as New Jersey requires.